Fresh Ingredients, Authentic New York-Style Pizza at NY Pie
When it comes to pizza, quality starts with the ingredients. At NY Pie, a local Nashville pizzeria, every pizza is crafted using the freshest, highest-quality ingredients — because great pizza starts long before it hits the brick oven.
The NY Pie Secret
People often ask – what’s the secret? Is it in the water? Here’s the answer – no. You need to “know your dough.” The recipe is not static & changes with humidity and temperatures. So, our expert dough makers flex the recipe accordingly and regularly adjust based on look and feel. Our dough makers prepare multiple batches of dough in the stores daily - 50 lbs. of flour at a time. While the secret is not necessarily in the water, the trick (competitors pay attention!) is filtering the water.
And for the rest of the secret -- we only use Grande cheese – the absolute best (& not inexpensive) cheese on the market, fresh vegetables, and high-quality meats.
Made from Scratch
From dough to sauce, marinara, garlic knots, salad dressings, and chocolate chip cookies – with few exceptions – we believe strongly in making it from scratch. Toppings include hand-selected vegetables, premium meats, and the finest Grande cheese. Every pizza is a showcase of freshness and flavor, staying true to the authentic New York-style pizza experience.
Authentic New York Flavor in Nashville
From the first slice to the last, NY Pie delivers a genuine taste of New York in Tennessee. Each pizza is baked to perfection in a brick oven, creating that signature flavor and texture that make New York-style pizza so iconic. Whether you’re visiting for a quick lunch or a family dinner, NY Pie brings the city’s famous pizza culture right to Nashville.
More Than Just a Pizza Restaurant
As a Nashville pizzeria, NY Pie isn’t just about food — it’s about creating an experience. The welcoming atmosphere, carefully crafted menu, and dedication to freshness make every visit memorable. Locals and visitors alike know that for the best pizza in Nashville, NY Pie is the go-to destination.
